faith in action

Many Hands: COP31 Update #11

Thursday's theme at COP31 was İmece, a Turkish tradition that COP31 President Murat Kurum described at the opening as "everyone doing their part when the task is too great for one person alone."


Protesters standing behind a long vinyl sign that reads "NO FALSE SOLUTIONS BUT REAL SOLUTIONS. Beside them, there is someone dressed in a villain costume next to a machine that says "Marine geoengineering"

Thursday’s theme at COP31 was İmece, a Turkish tradition that COP31 President Murat Kurum described at the opening as “everyone doing their part when the task is too great for one person alone.” On the eve of the final day, the main negotiating text showed how hard that is: a second draft left out fossil fuels entirely and put off key decisions on money for adaptation. Around the venue, others showed what doing their part can look like: cities keeping water running through blackouts, young people from the Arctic speaking up, and countries planning an exit from fossil fuels on their own.

In the negotiations

Australia, which is steering the negotiations, released the second draft of the main political text on Thursday afternoon. At half the length of Monday’s, it drops both of that text’s references to fossil fuels, including the first global stocktake’s call to transition away from them. Türkiye’s electrification goal survives only as a call for global cooperation, and the draft encourages scaling up carbon capture and removal, with a target for carbon capture still in brackets. The text says the Paris Agreement is working, yet projects about 2.6°C of warming even if countries carry out their current plans, and it does not mention human rights, a just transition or gender equality.

On adaptation, the draft drops the figure of $120 billion a year by 2035 that developing countries were pushing for, which we reported on Monday. Instead of settling how to deliver last year’s pledge to triple adaptation finance, it proposes an “Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap” to work that out by next year’s COP32 in Ethiopia, against the wishes of African and least developed countries. The draft also repeats a gap we reported last week: requests to the loss and damage fund total about $2.8 billion, against about $342 million allocated, and only half of the $822 million pledged to the fund has been paid in.

Money is also at the heart of a fight over technology. The Climate Technology Centre and Network, hosted by the UN Environment Programme, is the UN climate process’s arm for helping developing countries get the technology they need to cut emissions and adapt. Its review at COP31 has been heavily contested. African, least developed and small island countries called for stable, predictable funding and real technology transfer, not just plans, while the EU and Norway opposed naming developed countries as the ones to pay. Least developed countries also asked that the UN Environment Programme be formally confirmed as host. The presidency reported progress on both items midweek.

Reactions to the draft were sharp. Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa said the text “has gone backwards” and warned of a “ghost COP” with nothing to show for it. Greenpeace said the carbon removal language could let fossil fuel production keep growing. Australia said Monday’s broad draft was always meant to be narrowed down, and this version is not expected to be the last. A separate consultation on making the UN climate process work better showed the same divisions: small island states pushed for change, while the Arab Group, Russia and like-minded developing countries said the consultations had served their purpose. The talks are due to end on Friday, but recent COPs have often run more than a day over.

Planning an exit

With fossil fuels missing from the draft, some countries are working elsewhere. At a side event on the road from Santa Marta, Colombia, where countries met in April for the first international conference on moving away from fossil fuels, to the next one, co-hosted by Tuvalu and Ireland in 2027, speakers said the talks are stuck on whether to name fossil fuels at all rather than how to move away from them. “When you are not able to address the cause of the climate crisis in the space, you have to think differently,” one said. Developed countries should move first, speakers agreed, and developing countries need debt relief and affordable finance to cover the upfront cost of renewable energy.

Water never stops

Water barely appears on COP31’s agenda, speakers at the Ukraine pavilion said, yet water and energy cannot be separated. In Ukraine, where the war has repeatedly damaged the power grid, pumps and treatment plants stop when the electricity does. Cities have installed solar panels and batteries at water facilities and hospitals so taps keep running through outages, which also cuts emissions. Water facilities use about 4% of the world’s electricity, one speaker said, so making them efficient pays twice. Simple systems are working elsewhere too: in Türkiye, a new deposit-return system for bottles and cans collected 660 million containers in its first four months, and similar systems in Germany, the Netherlands and the Nordic countries recover 90 to 98% of containers, speakers at a session on zero waste said.

What happens in the Arctic

Young people from the Nordic countries presented a statement drawn from about 200 youth. One speaker described winter rain freezing into sheets of ice so reindeer cannot reach their food, and Greenland sea ice that is now “too thick to fish and too thin to hunt.” “We are tired of being tired,” the statement said. “We remain hopeful, resilient, proud.” What happens in the Arctic does not stay there: a researcher from India explained that shrinking Arctic sea ice is shifting India’s monsoon rains, with consequences for food. As new shipping lanes open, a Korean shipping expert urged that Arctic shipping be judged by what it leaves behind for local communities, not by how many ships pass through. Shipping is a lifeline elsewhere, too. The Marshall Islands’ ambassador noted that his country’s land, about the size of Washington, D.C., is spread across an ocean area the size of Mexico, and much of it can be reached only by sea.

Where the church comes in

Next year’s COP32 will meet in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and Thursday’s draft already points there. Africa is home to millions of United Methodists, so the church can help African voices be heard on the road to Addis Ababa. Congregations with partners on the continent can start that conversation now: what do they hope COP32 will deliver, and how can churches elsewhere stand with them?

Follow our updates throughout COP31, share them with your congregation, and hold in prayer those working to turn commitments into action.