faith_in_action

Not Yet: COP31 Update #12

Friday was meant to be COP31's last day. At midnight in Antalya, there was still no agreement.


Protesters line up outside at COP31

Friday was meant to be COP31’s last day. At midnight in Antalya, there was still no agreement. The closing plenary was suspended until Saturday morning, with a third draft of the main decision promised overnight. After two weeks of listening to people whose homes, harvests and ways of life are already being lost, Friday was a day for grief, and for refusing to give up.

In the negotiations

Thursday’s draft, which drops every reference to fossil fuels and the $120 billion adaptation figure, is still the basis for talks. The fossil fuel language came out after objections from several oil and gas producing countries. Panama’s environment minister said, “It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover document that does not even mention fossil fuels.” Uganda warned that leaning on carbon removal would let wealthy countries keep producing oil and gas while developing countries carry more of the burden. Vanuatu said of the next draft, “We can see where it’s going, and it’s not going to be a high-ambition text.” Australia’s Chris Bowen, who is steering the negotiations, said he remained hopeful of a deal everyone could support: “Things worth doing, in my experience, don’t come easy.”

Late Friday night, the closing session approved a set of routine decisions but put off several harder questions until next year, including support for climate technology in developing countries, which we reported on Thursday, and guidance for countries’ national climate plans. Small island states and Latin American countries said they regretted that language on limiting warming to 1.5°C had been dropped.

One moment pointed ahead. Ethiopia, host of COP32 in Addis Ababa next year, accepted the role “with humility and resolve.” Recalling its marathon runners, it invited the world to “run the next leg with us,” with three goals: restore hope, rebuild trust and mobilize collective action.

Disappointed, troubled, resolute

The ecumenical delegation, which our United Methodist delegation is part of, reflected on the two weeks at a press conference hosted by the World Council of Churches. ACT Alliance’s coordinator in Zimbabwe, who has walked these halls for years, described herself as “disappointed, troubled, resolute.” She said the ethical compass is missing from the talks: care for creation and love of neighbor are not negotiable, and “every time explicit fossil fuel language is removed, we are trading away the future of our children not yet born.” She added that faith groups are “not on the sidelines of COP praying,” but working alongside frontline communities.

The head of a Lutheran relief agency in Nepal, whom we heard from on Wednesday, said three disasters struck Nepal within months this year, damaging more than 15,000 homes and causing some $3 billion in losses. “Solidarity without accountability is not justice,” she said. A young Indigenous Toraja delegate from Indonesia, representing her church, said forests were burning in Papua even as COP31 met. “The elders tell us that the design of nature no longer matches,” she said. Young people in her community are recording their elders’ stories in their own languages, so that what the fires took is not forgotten.

Home

At a press conference on climate displacement, speakers noted that disasters are forcing millions of people from their homes every year, and that recent floods and landslides in Nepal displaced 10,800 families. What is lost, they said, is not only a house but a livelihood, a sense of belonging and a community to call home.

Where the church comes in

Our delegation ends these two weeks heartbroken but hopeful. Heartbroken for the families in Nepal rebuilding after three disasters in one year, for Pacific communities watching the sea take the places of their grandparents, and for Indigenous communities whose forests burned while the nations met. Hopeful because we saw communities, young people and churches already doing the work, and because this process, for all its frustrations, is still the one place where the smallest island nation sits at the same table as the largest economy. We believe it can still deliver.

We ask United Methodists to pray tonight and tomorrow for the negotiators returning to the table and for the communities waiting on their decisions. We are not giving up. The work continues at home, and next year in Addis Ababa.

Read the delegation’s full report from the day, and follow our updates. We will publish another update once we learn more about the final decisions.