action

Learning to Listen: COP31 Update #10

Wednesday was COP31's day for people: livelihoods, local knowledge, vulnerable groups and a just transition.


Jacob Stone, a white man with short brown hair and a beard stands by a sign that reads "DIALOGUE CONSENSUS ACTION"
COP31 delegate Jacob Stone, Michigan Annual Conference

Wednesday was COP31’s day for people: livelihoods, local knowledge, vulnerable groups and a just transition. With the talks due to end on Friday, Türkiye’s presidency tried a new format for the negotiations, a “Divan,” named for the council of the Ottoman Empire, where senior officials were asked to talk with one another instead of reading statements. Across the venue, communities and faith groups asked the talks for the same thing: to listen. As a community leader from the Philippines put it, being consulted is not the same as being heard.

In the negotiations

The first draft of COP31’s main political text is still a catch-all, and the objections we reported on Tuesday have not eased: the Arab Group and Russia still reject it. Senior officials were due to meet in the Divan on Wednesday evening to look for common ground on “a balanced package,” and it was not yet clear when the next draft would appear. Money remains the sorest point. A pledging session on Tuesday raised only $50 million for the Adaptation Fund, a UN fund that pays for projects helping communities cope with climate impacts, against an annual target of $300 million. Some work is running out of time: a draft decision would push talks on national adaptation plans, countries’ plans for coping with a changing climate, to June 2027 and to next year’s COP32. Ministers also launched the second global stocktake, the review of the world’s progress under the Paris Agreement, due to conclude in 2028.

Behind the week’s frustration lies a bigger question about how COPs decide. Every decision needs consensus, and Panama’s environment minister said that leaves the talks “doomed to failure.” Others, including Saudi Arabia and the African Group, oppose majority voting, arguing that no country’s interests should be sacrificed for another’s.

Faith at the table

At a dialogue on the ethics of climate action, hosted by the Interfaith Liaison Committee, a network of faith groups that engages with the UN climate process, speakers argued that the crisis is ethical as well as technical. The head of ACT Alliance, a global alliance of churches and church-related organizations, left the room with a question: when future generations look back at COP31, will they see the best agreement countries could negotiate, or the courage to do what justice required?

The head of a Lutheran relief agency in Nepal, who worked alongside local churches as first responders after this year’s glacial floods, said handing out food is not enough; aid workers also need to sit with people, hear how they are feeling and play with the children. In the Netherlands, a Muslim group is building a “green mosque” and bringing climate and environmental justice into Friday sermons, something a speaker called new for Muslim communities in Europe. Faith groups are also building a “global ethical stocktake,” first proposed by Brazil’s COP30 presidency, to bring the voices of faith communities into the next global stocktake. Organizers said it is still taking shape and welcome contributions.

Heard, not just consulted

Local leaders from across Asia showed what their communities already know how to do. Bangladesh, which we wrote about last week, offered one example. In the north of the country, where families lose land and homes to riverbank erosion every monsoon, villagers build river defenses from bamboo grown at their own homes, at about 5% of the cost of concrete embankments, a community leader said. On a small Indonesian island where fresh water is scarce and costly, women documented their own needs and proposed solar-powered water purification, but the local government gave it no budget. In Cambodia, a network of civil society groups helped get child protection into the country’s national climate plan. “Nothing about the community without the community,” its director said.

Where the minerals come from

Darina Regio, Church and Society Director of Environmental Justice.

Türkiye’s goal to raise electricity’s share of the world’s energy use to 35% by 2035, which dozens of countries have backed, raised a question speakers kept returning to: where will the minerals come from, and who will bear the cost? On Sibuyan Island in the Philippines, communities that protect their forests now face large-scale mining for battery and solar-panel minerals. In South America’s lithium triangle, the salt flats that hold lithium also sustain wetlands and Indigenous livelihoods. Brazil’s government described its work removing illegal miners from Indigenous lands in the Amazon and keeping them from returning. A Baré leader from the Upper Rio Negro described a solar lab his people run with university partners on their own land. His people have been living an energy transition for thousands of years, he said, but “the crisis in listening is bigger than the climate crisis.”

Letting the global South become a sacrifice zone for minerals, a young speaker from Mexico said, would not be a just transition. A session on minerals and rights closed with examples of a fairer path: in Bolivia, communities cook with solar stoves and run solar-powered fish farms, many led by women and young people; in Brazil, a network of women farmers uses rainwater harvesting and biodigesters to strengthen their harvests.

Where the church comes in

Two things from Wednesday are within reach of any congregation. A UN official said the new global stocktake is a chance to include stories from the ground, so congregations can start recording, in their own words, how climate change is already affecting their neighbors. And as a forum on ageing reminded delegates, about 2.1 billion people will be over 60 by 2050. Congregations are among the few places where every generation still meets each week, which makes them good places to plan together for heat, floods and other changes ahead.


Follow our updates throughout COP31, share them with your congregation, and hold in prayer those working to turn commitments into action.