Everyone Has to Eat: COP31 Update #8
Everyone has to eat, and on Monday at COP31 the food on our plates led all the way back to the forests of Brazil.
As the conference’s second week opened and ministers began arriving to settle what negotiators could not, sessions on food, work and young people asked what it takes to turn climate plans into practice.
From forest to plate
At a session on ending deforestation by 2030, Brazilian and European groups described how they are tracking beef and soy, the foods most often linked to forest loss. In Mato Grosso, a state that grows about a tenth of the world’s soy and cotton, most clearing now happens legally on private land, said Alice Thuault of Instituto Centro de Vida, so new tools are needed.
Markets are starting to respond. Brazil’s first certification for beef free of illegal deforestation and slave labor, Beef on Track, was designed to meet demand from China, where a group of importers has committed to buy at least 50,000 tons of certified beef. In the European Union, a new law will require beef, soy, coffee, cocoa, wood and other goods to be proven free of deforestation. Compliance is a tool, not the goal, said Celeste Righi Ricco of Change for Planet. Speakers agreed that ending deforestation by 2030 is still possible, if companies, governments and buyers all use the data they now have.
Governments are putting money into standing forests, too. On Monday, Canada announced a loan of up to C$560 million to the Tropical Forest Forever Facility, the fund we reported on last week, which rewards countries for keeping tropical forests intact. It is still about $1.8 billion short of its $10 billion goal.
Plans, and the means to carry them out
At a high-level event, Türkiye and Australia, which are leading this year’s talks, joined Azerbaijan and Brazil, hosts of the two previous conferences, to present a joint report on turning countries’ climate plans into action. Its message, as speakers put it: the Paris Agreement is working, but progress is too slow, too narrow and too uneven. The solutions exist; what is too often missing are the conditions to deliver them. Bhutan put it simply: “Our challenge is not lack of plans but lack of resources.” Tonga added that carbon removal must not become a cover for continued fossil fuel use, so that Pacific children can still play on the beach.
At a side event, the countries behind April’s first international conference on moving away from fossil fuels, held in Santa Marta, Colombia, described a coalition that has grown to 57 countries, together accounting for a fifth of fossil fuel production and a third of consumption. Tuvalu and Ireland will co-host its next conference in 2027.
In the negotiations, the first draft of COP31’s main political text came out on Monday, and the divisions we reported last week remain. Arab and like-minded developing countries still oppose new sectoral targets, including Türkiye’s voluntary goal to raise electricity’s share of the world’s final energy use to 35% by 2035. Even supporters are flexible: Germany backs the goal but said it need not appear in the final text. Developing countries want the pledge to triple adaptation finance defined as at least $120 billion a year by 2035, while developed countries have little new money to offer.
Workers at the center
Last week, we reported on communities living near the mines that supply clean energy minerals asking for a say in the energy transition. On Monday, it was workers’ turn. At a session on inequality and climate change, trade unions argued that a just transition, one that is fair to the people whose livelihoods depend on today’s energy system, starts with workers’ rights: the freedom to organize and safe working conditions, including protection from extreme heat. A speaker from Norway, where about 8% of jobs come from oil and gas, said the aim is to move workers into new jobs rather than simply close workplaces, and that the biggest obstacle is connecting new industries to the power grid. The Dominican Republic urged attention to women, many of whom work in food systems that climate change will hit hard.
Public Services International, a global federation of public service unions, added that resilience should not fall on individuals and communities alone. Strong public services for water, housing and health are the bulwark, it said.
They live with it
At an event on Action for Climate Empowerment, the UN track on climate education and public participation, young people and educators described themselves as part of the response, not its audience. Anaïs Salabert, a teacher with the Science Panel for the Amazon’s Youth Advisory Committee who works with Indigenous youth in Brazil, shared what they taught her: they do not live in the forest; they live with it. Robert Karoro, an Indigenous representative from Kiribati, said Indigenous knowledge has been tested over centuries of lived experience, and ignoring it harms everyone. In Türkiye, a conversation that began in schools became a national survey and fed into the country’s climate plan, said Nazya Ürek of Climate Envoys of Türkiye.
#Where the church comes in Week by week, congregations around the world pray, “Give us this day our daily bread,” and churches gather around food more than almost anything else. Advent, which begins on November 29, is a good season to ask where that food comes from. Congregations can share a meal of dishes grown or made close to home, eat lower on the food chain through Advent or Lent, serve fair trade coffee at fellowship time, or plant a garden of crops native to the area. Asking whether the beef or soy we buy is tied to cleared forest is one way to love neighbors we will never meet.
The church has stood with workers before. In 1908, the Methodist Episcopal Church adopted the Social Creed, the first statement of its kind by a church, calling for an end to child labor, a living wage and safer workplaces, commitments that live on in the church’s Social Principles today. A just transition asks the same of the green economy: that it not become a new form of exploitation.
Follow our updates throughout COP31, share them with your congregation, and hold in prayer those working to turn commitments into action.