Connected to the Earth: COP31 Update #9
Across the venue, speakers returned to one conviction: land, water and people belong together, and those who live closest to the land are often its best protectors.
Tuesday was COP31’s day for oceans, forests, land and nature, and a new task force was launched to help countries write ocean protection into their national climate plans. Across the venue, speakers returned to one conviction: land, water and people belong together, and those who live closest to the land are often its best protectors. In the negotiating rooms, with the talks due to end on Friday, the divisions we reported on Monday hardened.
In the negotiations
The first draft of COP31’s main political text met strong objections. Like-minded developing countries, a group that includes China, India and Saudi Arabia, said it crosses their red lines, objecting to Türkiye’s electrification goal, the roadmap for moving away from fossil fuels and calls to cut methane quickly. The Arab Group and Russia rejected the draft outright. Developed countries were quieter, since the text includes most of their priorities, though the European Union called it a “shopping list” that needs significant change on finance and trade. On money, the poorest countries want continued work toward tripling adaptation finance, while the EU and Switzerland want no new financial commitments. Small island states also said any delay to the next major report from the IPCC, the UN’s climate science panel, would be unjustifiable, while Saudi Arabia said the timeline should leave enough room for scientific review and participation. Australia, which is steering the negotiations, said at least one more draft will come before the week ends.
Methane, one of the disputed goals, was the focus of a side event the same day. China’s vice minister of ecology and environment said the country’s 2035 climate plan includes methane and other gases beyond carbon dioxide, and the UN Environment Programme invited China to work with it on tracking methane and cutting it from coal mines. An EU envoy, citing the International Energy Agency, said about 40% of methane emissions from fossil fuels can be cut at no net cost.
A subject, not an object
At an event on the rights of nature, Jocabed Solano, a Guna theologian and member of Panama’s negotiating team, described her people’s bond with creation: “We are connected to the earth by an umbilical cord that was never cut.” Speakers asked that the law treat nature as a subject with rights, not an object to be owned. That idea is gaining ground. In 2022, Panama passed a law recognizing nature’s right to exist, persist and regenerate, and speakers said a coalition of countries is forming to carry the idea further. In Europe, citizens are gathering signatures to ask the European Union to recognize the rights of nature, including rivers. Casey Camp-Horinek, an elder of the Ponca Nation in Oklahoma, said it plainly: “The air is not for sale.”
A session on water for farms and cities took up a related question: what we value. Researchers from Italy and Türkiye, working with partners in Morocco and Colombia, argued that every water project carries values, whether or not anyone names them: the health of rivers, fair access to water and sanitation, cultural identity, and spiritual and faith understandings of water. Naming those values openly, with farmers, water companies and governments at the same table, helps projects deliver what communities need. In Colombia, where a third of municipalities face the risk of water shortages despite the country’s abundant water, one program found that nine of its ten priority actions could be done within five years, mostly through better coordination.
The first line of defense
On forests, speakers showed how local people protect the land. Türkiye, where forests cover about 30% of the land and some 7 million people live in forest villages, said technology and aircraft matter, but the first line of defense against wildfire is local people. It trains villagers, helps villages plan for fire prevention and supports livelihoods for 10,000 families so they can stay and care for the land. Australia pointed to Indigenous fire stewardship practiced for thousands of years. A speaker of Maya descent from Guatemala said that wherever forest still stands, local and Indigenous communities are working to protect it, and in the Brazilian Amazon, fishing agreements involving 1,600 families have made conservation last.
That work is growing more urgent. Fires are becoming more frequent and intense in many regions, from Central Africa to Japan. Scientists at a UN Environment Programme event said the vast northern forests of Canada, Scandinavia and Russia, home to the Sámi and other Indigenous peoples, are among the most exposed. Speakers called for planning for the whole cycle, from prevention to recovery, not only for fighting fires.
Islands lead the way
At a session on turning last year’s commitments in Belém into results, speakers said ocean projects are growing but money is not keeping pace. Several countries signed on Tuesday to include at least one ocean measure in their national climate plans, and speakers pointed to a new $30 million investment in coral reefs across 22 developing countries. Island communities offered some of the clearest examples. On Rapa Nui, also known as Easter Island, a plan covering both land and sea is led largely by the Rapa Nui people themselves. In Palau, fish and birds have returned where the links between coral, fish and people were restored. Islands, one speaker said, are not only on the front line; they can lead the restoration of the ocean.
Losses that cannot be counted
Some of what climate change takes cannot be measured in money. At an event on health and climate loss, Pacific speakers described losses to culture, identity, mental health and spiritual life, known in the talks as non-economic loss and damage. A health advocate from Fiji spoke of rising waters “washing away the places of our grandfathers.” A climate advocate from Tuvalu said extreme heat affects not only the body but how people think and treat one another. A youth ocean advocate described young Pacific Islanders planting coral near their villages, only to see repeated heat waves undo the work. A Pacific researcher said the knowledge of these losses is not missing; our systems are simply not built to see it.
Where the church comes in
Methodism has deep roots across the Pacific, including in Fiji and Tonga, so many of the families facing these losses belong to the wider Methodist family. Health researchers said they need faith communities to help understand and respond to these losses. That is work congregations already do.
Follow our updates throughout COP31, share them with your congregation, and hold in prayer those working to turn commitments into action.